Prop Firm Challenge Monte Carlo

Thousands of traders with zero skill — pure random-walk P&L, no edge whatsoever — attempt a two-stage funded-trader challenge. They differ in exactly one thing: how big they size their bets. Watch how many pass the paid evaluation on variance alone, then watch the funded stage take it all back.

arXiv:2609.14859 — Gate Design & Stage-Dependent Incentives in Retail Prop-Trading Evaluations
Ready — press run to simulate zero-edge traders.
Evaluation Pass Rate
—
skill-free traders, pure sizing
Funded Payout Rate (of eval passers)
—
same size, real drawdown rule
Gate Gap
—
how much easier the eval is than getting paid

Stage 1 — Paid Evaluation

Hit the profit target before the trailing drawdown catches you. Bigger size = faster resolution = more shots at landing on the green side purely from variance.

Pass 0 Fail (drawdown) 0 Timeout 0

Stage 2 — Funded Account

No profit target to stop at — just survive the trading window under the same trailing drawdown rule. The same sizing that won the eval keeps swinging, and a driftless random walk against a fixed barrier is a near-certain eventual hit.

Paid 0 Blew Up 0 Pending eval passers 0