A model says a team has a 65% chance to win. Is that a long-run frequency, or a one-time belief? Turns out: both — and here's the picture that makes it click.
Set a "true" win probability p, then replay the same bet thousands of times. No single replay matters — watch the empirical win rate crawl toward p as the Law of Large Numbers does its thing, live, in your browser.
This game happens once. There is no "long run" to average over — only your current state of belief given the evidence in front of you. Drag the news sliders and watch your credence (and how tightly you hold it) update live.
Here's the trick: pool together hundreds of different one-off games, each with its own stated probability, each played exactly once (just like panel 2). No single game repeats — but if you bin games by their stated probability and check how often the predicted side actually won in each bin, a well-calibrated model traces the diagonal. Frequency emerges from the aggregate even though no individual event was ever itself repeated. That's the reconciliation the paper is making precise.