A toy sportsbook crowd — regular public money plus a swarm of ratio-sensitive contrarians — argues in groups of three. Crank the contrarian-activation dial and watch the exact moment "fade the public" stops being a strategy, because the public itself has gone chaotic and never settles on a side.
Based on the mechanism in "Ratio-Dependent Contrarian Activation in Opinion Dynamics" · arXiv 2604.27226 (physics.soc-ph)
Every round, all 240 agents are shuffled into random triads. Each triad is either a 3–0 sweep (unanimous) or a 2–1 split. Conformists always align to their triad's local majority — that's the classic Galam majority rule. Contrarians instead ask "how lopsided was my triad?" and flip to the local minority with a probability that grows with that lopsidedness, raised to the activation exponent α — the dial above.
The local ratio is Laplace-smoothed to stay finite even when the minority is empty:
At α = 0, p_flip = 0 for everyone — pure majority rule, bistable, the crowd locks onto one side exactly like a normal fadeable public. As α rises, contrarians in already-unanimous triads (ratio 7) start defecting far more aggressively than contrarians in narrow 2–1 triads (ratio 5/3) — exactly the "more lopsided → more likely to flip" rule from the paper.
Writing the exact mean-field recursion for the population-wide majority fraction
x (this swarm runs 90% contrarian, 10% conformist) gives a closed-form update
equation x' = F(x, α). The balanced point x = 1/2 is always a fixed
point by symmetry; its stability flips when F'(1/2) = −1. Solving that condition
numerically for this swarm's 90% contrarian density gives the critical exponent marked on the
dial: α* ≈ 3.75 (slider ≈ 70%). Below it, perturbations from 50/50 decay — the crowd
settles. Above it, perturbations grow and flip sign every single round — a permanent 2-1 churn
that never converges, visible directly in the live chart as it starts alternating between
roughly 0.85 and 0.15 every tick.
Between the α≈0 lock-in and the α*≈3.75 chaos onset sits a quieter stretch where the crowd still settles — just at a dead 50/50, no exploitable majority at all. That's the "Coinflip Zone": fading does nothing because there's no consistent side to fade. Betting framing aside, this three-regime shape (lock-in → neutral equilibrium → permanent oscillation) is the real qualitative shape of a contrarian-density bifurcation in the group-size-3 Galam model.